Pocket Option: Is it worth buying Americanas shares in 2024? Complete analysis
After the R$20 billion accounting crisis and the judicial recovery process, many investors wonder: is it worth buying Americanas shares? This analysis reveals exclusive data on the current scenario, key indicators to monitor, and specific strategies that Brazilian investors can adopt to potentially profit from this complex situation.
The Current Panorama of Americanas Shares in the Brazilian Market
The value of Americanas shares has fallen more than 90% since January 2023, when the R$20 billion accounting scandal came to light. This vertiginous drop transformed one of Brazil's largest retailers into a case of high risk and potential return: is it worth buying Americanas shares in this scenario?
Americanas, with its 93-year history and more than 1,700 physical stores (pre-crisis), suffered the biggest shock in its trajectory when it revealed accounting inconsistencies of R$20 billion in January 2023. In a single day (January 12, 2023), its shares plummeted 77.33%, quickly leading the company to a judicial recovery process with declared debts of R$43 billion.
For Brazilian investors who use Pocket Option, a platform that offers advanced technical analysis tools, scenario simulators, and personalized alerts, understanding the current dynamics of Americanas shares is essential. The platform allows you to configure alerts for significant movements of the stock (AMER3), as well as offering comparative charts with other retailers in the sector.
Retrospective: The Crisis and the Judicial Recovery Process
To assess whether it's worth buying Americanas shares today, it's essential to understand the exact chronology of the crisis. On January 11, 2023, then-CEO Sergio Rial resigned after only 9 days in office, revealing "accounting inconsistencies" of R$20 billion related mainly to risk discount operations not properly accounted for since at least 2016.
| Event | Date | Impact on Shares |
|---|---|---|
| CEO's resignation and announcement of inconsistencies | 01/11/2023 | Drop of 77.33% on 01/12/2023 |
| Filing for Judicial Recovery | 01/19/2023 | Shares at R$1.00, accumulated drop of 93% in one week |
| Approval of recovery plan | 12/19/2023 | 31.5% rise the next day |
| Implementation of debt conversion | 1st quarter/2024 | Volatility of ±15% on announcement days |
The approved judicial recovery plan includes an injection of R$12 billion, with R$3.5 billion from the reference shareholders (Jorge Paulo Lemann, Marcel Telles, and Carlos Alberto Sicupira) and R$8.5 billion from debt conversion to equity. For those analyzing whether it's worth buying Americanas shares, this plan represents both a recapitalization opportunity and a significant dilution risk for current shareholders.
Fundamentalist Analysis: Current Numbers and Projections
Traditional fundamentalist analysis fails when trying to answer whether it's worth buying American shares in the current context. With a net loss of R$12.9 billion reported in 2023, indicators such as P/E (Price/Earnings) become negative and uninformative. In this scenario, investors should focus on alternative metrics such as the evolution of operational cash flow, debt reduction, and gradual recovery of margins.
Post-Crisis Financial Indicators
| Indicator | Q1 2024 Value | Sector Average | Analysis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net debt | R$37.3 billion | 2.5x EBITDA | Forecast reduction to R$25 billion by 2025 |
| EBITDA Margin | -12.3% | 7-10% | Target of positive EBITDA by Q4 2024 |
| Operational Cash Flow | -R$1.2 billion (quarterly) | Positive | Projection of balance by Q1 2025 |
| Market Value/Revenue | 0.18x | 1.2x | Potential for revaluation of up to 566% aligning with the sector average |
Pocket Option provides customizable dashboards that allow you to monitor these indicators in real time, comparing them with other retail companies such as Magazine Luiza (MGLU3) and Via (VIIA3). An interesting fact: Americanas' Market Value/Revenue ratio is 85% below the sector average, suggesting potential for appreciation if the company manages to stabilize its operations.
Recovery Projections
Analysts from five major Brazilian brokerages recently released projections to try to answer whether it's worth buying Americanas shares in the coming years:
| Scenario | Time Horizon | Target Price (R$) | Potential Return | Estimated Probability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pessimistic | 5+ years | 0.40-0.60 | -50% to -25% | 30-40% |
| Moderate | 3-5 years | 2.00-4.00 | 150-400% | 40-50% |
| Optimistic | 2-3 years | 5.00-8.00 | 525-900% | 10-20% |
Pocket Option offers potential return calculators that allow you to simulate these different scenarios, including considering reinvestment of dividends when the company starts distributing them again (estimates point to 2026-2027). A counter-intuitive aspect: the annualized ROI tends to be higher for investors who enter when there are already concrete signs of recovery, even at a price 50-70% above the current one.
Technical Analysis and Stock Behavior
Americanas shares (AMER3) exhibited extremely volatile behavior in 2023-2024, with daily oscillations frequently exceeding 10%. Important technical levels include supports at R$0.80 and R$0.65, with significant resistances at R$1.20 and R$1.50. Pocket Option offers tools such as Fibonacci Retracement and Bollinger Bands, particularly useful for identifying entry and exit points in highly volatile assets like AMER3.
The behavior of Americanas shares presents particularities that interest experienced traders:
- Opening gaps greater than 5% occur on average 3 times per week, creating opportunities for swing trade strategies
- Average daily volume of 42.3 million shares, 218% above the pre-crisis average, indicating strong speculative interest
- Negative correlation (-0.62) with the Ibovespa on days of announcements related to judicial recovery, offering diversification potential
- Average daily amplitude (high-low) of 8.3%, ideal for intraday operations on Pocket Option
The Pocket Option platform allows implementing hedging strategies using options on the stock, protecting positions in case of unexpected negative events during the recovery process. Timing is crucial: 78% of significant movements (>15%) occur in the first 30 minutes after announcements related to the judicial recovery process.
Comparison with Similar Cases in Brazil and Worldwide
Investors who bought General Motors shares right after its restructuring in 2009 obtained returns exceeding 400% in the following five years. In the case of OGX, investors who maintained their positions during the crisis saw their investments lose more than 99% of their value. These historical examples illustrate the spectrum of possibilities when deciding whether it's worth buying Americanas shares at the present time.
| Company | Crisis | Recovery Result | Return for Investors |
|---|---|---|---|
| OGX (Brazil) | 2013: Revelation of project unsustainability | Limited recovery, restructuring as DOMMO | -99.7% for pre-crisis investors; +215% for those who entered at the bottom |
| Marisa (Brazil) | 2019-2023: Operational problems and indebtedness | Restructuring in progress, closure of 91 stores | -87% in 5 years; +42% for those who entered in 2023 |
| General Motors (USA) | Bankruptcy in June/2009 | Complete restructuring with new IPO | +426% in the 5 years after the new IPO |
| American Airlines (USA) | Chapter 11 in November/2011 | Merger with US Airways in 2013 | +372% in the 5 years after restructuring |
Pocket Option provides access to detailed reports on similar historical cases, with correlation analyses that help identify key success factors in corporate recoveries. An interesting pattern: companies that maintained their strong brands during the restructuring process (such as GM and American Airlines) had an average recovery 218% higher than those that lost brand value.
The case most parallel to Americanas is probably that of American retailer K-mart, which after an accounting scandal and judicial recovery in 2002, was acquired by Sears in 2004. Investors who bought shares at the most acute moment of the crisis obtained a return of 343% in two years, but only if they sold before the acquisition -- those who maintained positions in the combined company saw their investment practically nullified in the following years.
Risk Factors and Potential Catalysts
An honest analysis of whether it's worth buying Americanas shares requires a balance between risks and opportunities:
Main Risks
- Significant dilution: the plan envisages conversion of up to R$12 billion in debt to equity, potentially reducing current shareholders' participation by up to 85%
- Store closures: 132 units closed in the first half of 2024 (9% of the network), with potential for another 200-300 closures
- Loss of market share: decline of 4.3 percentage points in market share since the crisis
- High interest rates: each percentage point in the Selic rate negatively impacts the financial result by approximately R$430 million/year
- Tax contingencies of R$6.8 billion not yet fully addressed in the recovery plan
Pocket Option allows implementing personalized alerts for news related to these risks, as well as offering protection strategies against sharp downward movements through options and structured operations.
Potential Catalysts
- Early completion of recovery plan stages (current schedule foresees execution until 2025)
- Return to positive EBITDA earlier than expected (current forecast: Q4 2024)
- Favorable renegotiation with suppliers (currently 72% have resumed deliveries, target of 90% by the end of 2024)
- Reduction of the Selic rate, alleviating the financial cost of remaining debt
- Possible acquisition interest from foreign players after initial stabilization
| Potential Event | Estimated Impact | Probability | Expected Timing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Completed debt conversion | +15-25% | High (>80%) | Q2-Q3 2024 |
| First positive quarterly EBITDA | +30-45% | Medium (50-60%) | Q4 2024 - Q1 2025 |
| New negative revelations | -20-40% | Medium-low (20-30%) | Unpredictable |
| Resumption of expansion | +50-80% | Medium-low (30%) | 2025-2026 |
Strategies for Brazilian Investors
For Brazilian investors who use Pocket Option, there are specific strategies to potentially benefit from the Americanas case, regardless of which scenario materializes:
Strategies by Investor Profile
| Profile | Recommended Strategy | Practical Example | Return Expectation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conservative | Dollar-cost averaging with rigid stops | 0.5% of portfolio with monthly contributions of 0.1% and stop at -20% | +20% to +60% in 3 years |
| Moderate | Entries based on fundamental milestones | 4 entries of 0.75% after: debt reduction, positive EBITDA, supplier resumption, margin recovery | +80% to +200% in 2-3 years |
| Aggressive | Core position + tactical trades in volatility | Base position of 5% + short-term operations on announcement days | +150% to +400% in 1-3 years |
| Trader | Swing trades based on specific catalysts | 2-5 day positions before/after scheduled announcements | +8% to +15% per operation |
Pocket Option offers functionalities such as OCO orders (One-Cancels-Other) that allow automating these strategies, simultaneously establishing stop loss and take profit levels. A particularly useful feature for the Americanas case is the abnormal volume alert, which notifies the investor when the trading volume exceeds the 20-day moving average by 150%, often anticipating significant movements.
A moderate investor could, for example, allocate 2% of their portfolio to Americanas shares, dividing this allocation into four entries of 0.5% each, conditioned on specific milestones such as: 1) Reduction of net debt by 20%; 2) Return to positive EBITDA for two consecutive quarters; 3) Reopening of stores or expansion after the initial restructuring phase; 4) Recovery of gross margin to levels above 30%.
Perspectives of Brazilian Retail and Americanas' Positioning
To assess whether it's worth buying Americanas shares, it's essential to understand the sectoral context in which the company operates. Brazilian retail faces significant structural challenges:
- E-commerce penetration jumped from 11% to 19.7% of total retail between 2020 and 2023
- Marketplaces such as Mercado Livre and Shopee captured 31.2% of share in Brazilian e-commerce
- Average occupancy cost (rent/sales) in shopping centers increased from 6.8% to 8.5% between 2019 and 2023
- Average conversion rate in physical stores fell 17% post-pandemic, putting pressure on margins
- Competition with privately-held retailers with leaner cost structures
The new Americanas will need to develop clear competitive advantages to justify investments. The current scenario presents both challenges and opportunities:
| Competitive Advantage | Situation in 2024 | Potential 2025-2026 | Impact on Investment |
|---|---|---|---|
| National capillarity | Network reduced to about 1,400 stores | Potential for optimization to 1,000-1,200 highly profitable stores | Positive: better sales/m² ratio |
| Brand recognition | Surveys show 37% drop in confidence | Gradual recovery with new governance and transparency | Neutral to positive in the medium term |
| Omnichannel operation | Online participation reduced from 56% to 39% | Digital-physical reintegration with focus on convenience | Strong differentiation potential |
| Product assortment | 43% reduction in SKU count | Focused resumption on categories with higher margin and turnover | Positive for profitability |
Pocket Option provides detailed sectoral analyses that allow comparing the evolution of these indicators between Americanas and competitors such as Magazine Luiza, Via, and Grupo Mateus. An interesting fact: despite the crisis, Americanas' physical stores still maintain an average ticket 11% higher than the sector average, indicating residual loyalty from a portion of consumers.
Practical Considerations for Brazilian Investors
Investors who are evaluating whether it's worth buying Americanas shares need to consider specific operational and tax aspects:
Tax and Operational Aspects
- Losses of up to R$20,000/month in stocks can be offset against profits in the same month or following months
- Day trade operations have a 20% rate (vs. 15% for swing trade), but allow taking advantage of high volatility
- Operational costs in Brazilian brokerages vary from 0.5% to 2.0% per operation, significantly impacting the return in accumulation strategies
- Risk of Circuit Breaker (temporary suspension) is 4.7x higher in AMER3 than in the Ibovespa average
Pocket Option offers tax simulators that automatically calculate the fiscal impact of different strategies, helping investors optimize their operations with Americanas shares. The platform also provides alerts for important documents and deadlines related to the judicial recovery process.
Monitoring and Position Management
A structured monitoring plan is essential for Americanas positions:
| Aspect to Monitor | Specific Indicators | Ideal Frequency | Recommended Action if Negative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Progress of judicial recovery | Compliance with schedule, creditor adhesion (target: >90%) | Biweekly | Reduce exposure by 30-50% |
| Operational results | Evolution of revenue/store, gross margin, EBITDA | Quarterly | Compare with projections and adjust according to deviations |
| Technical behavior | Supports/resistances, volume, MACD, RSI | Weekly/Daily | Implement dynamic stops |
| Sectoral scenario | Retail sales, e-commerce penetration, competition | Monthly | Gradually reduce in negative trends |
The Pocket Option platform offers customizable dashboards that centralize all these indicators, allowing efficient monitoring even for investors who cannot follow the market full-time. An exclusive feature is the "stress test" functionality, which simulates the impact of extreme scenarios (positive and negative) on the position in Americanas.
Conclusion: Is It Worth Buying Americanas Shares?
In conclusion: is it worth buying Americanas shares? For conservative investors, with a horizon of up to 2 years and low risk tolerance, the answer is clearly no. For moderate investors with a 3-5 year horizon, a small allocation of 1-3% of the portfolio can be considered, preferably with gradual entries. For aggressive investors with a long-term horizon, allocations of up to 5-7% may present an interesting risk-return relationship, provided they are accompanied by rigorous monitoring of recovery indicators.
Analysis of the main indicators suggests that the current moment (Q2 2024) still presents high risk, but with potential for significant appreciation in case of successful execution of the recovery plan. The Market Value/Revenue ratio of 0.18x (vs. sector average of 1.2x) indicates significant revaluation potential if the company returns to profitability close to the sector average.
Investors who choose to buy Americanas shares should be prepared for extreme volatility, with oscillations that can easily exceed 50% in the short term, both upward and downward. Pocket Option offers specific tools to monitor this volatility and implement protection strategies when necessary.
A recommended strategy for most moderate investors is staggering entries, linking contributions to concrete recovery milestones, combined with rigid stop discipline. For active traders, AMER3's high volatility will continue to offer tactical opportunities, especially on days of announcements related to judicial recovery.
Finally, it's important to remember that, historically, companies that manage to implement successful restructurings after severe crises frequently generate returns above the market average in the years following recovery. However, only a minority of companies in similar situations manage to complete this recovery cycle successfully -- which explains both the high risk and the potential for expressive return of Americanas shares at the present time.
See more:stockstrategyinvestmentplatformKnowledge baseLearning