How to Buy Casey's General Stores, Inc. (CASY) Shares - Investment in Casey's General Stores, Inc. (CASY) Stock

📈 Current Stock Price and Market Position

As of September 10, 2025, Casey’s General Stores (CASY) is trading at $580.00 per share. The company has demonstrated impressive resilience in the convenience store sector, currently ranking as the third largest convenience store retailer in the United StatesCStore Dive.

Casey’s operates approximately 2,904 stores across 16 states, with a particularly strong presence in rural and small-town marketsCStore Dive. What makes Casey’s truly unique is its position as the fifth largest pizza chain in America—yes, those gas station pizzas have become a national phenomenon!

📅 Critical Earnings Date Alert

Mark your calendar: September 8, 2025 is the most recent earnings announcement date for Casey’s. This quarterly report typically causes significant price movements, making it a crucial date for both current shareholders and potential investors.

Historical Earnings Impact Analysis

Trend Insight: Casey’s typically experiences 3-8% price swings around earnings announcements. Positive surprises (like March 2025’s 8.2% jump) create excellent entry opportunities on any post-earnings dips.

📊 6-Month Price Performance Journey

Casey’s stock has delivered an impressive +14.02% return over the past six monthsMarketBeat, significantly outperforming many retail sector peers. Here’s the breakdown:

March 2025: $508 (post-Q3 earnings surge)
April 2025: $492 (normal consolidation)
May 2025: $515 (acquisition momentum)
June 2025: $535 (strong summer travel season)
July 2025: $527 (peak reached July 25th)
August 2025: $514-525 range (healthy pullback)
September 2025: $580 current level

The stock reached its all-time high of $527.51 on July 25, 2025Companies Market Cap, before experiencing a healthy 11% correction to current levels around $467. This represents typical profit-taking behavior after strong gains.

🔮 Price Forecast: 2025-2030 Outlook

Based on current analyst projections and company fundamentals, here’s what to expect:

Verdict: STRONG BUY for long-term investors. The current pullback from July highs offers an attractive entry point for patient capital.

⚠️ Key Investment Risks

Legal and Regulatory Challenges

Casey’s faces two class action lawsuits alleging overtime wage violations and health insurance surcharge issuesTop Class Actions. While the company denies wrongdoing, these cases could result in significant financial settlements and increased compliance costs.

Debt Load Concerns

The company carries $1.1 billion in acquisition-related debt, causing interest expenses to surge 91% to $26.8 million last quarter. With over $1 billion in variable-rate debt, rising interest rates could pressure profitability.

Margin Pressure

Prepared food gross margins declined slightly to 58.0% last quarter, impacted by integration costs from acquired CEFCO stores. Maintaining premium pricing power while expanding remains challenging.

🟢 Positive Growth Signals

Aggressive Expansion Strategy

Casey’s acquired over 270 new locations recently, including the significant Fikes Wholesale acquisition. This expansion should drive revenue growth and market share gains throughout 2026.

EV Infrastructure Investment

The company installed EV charging stations at 47 stores across 13 states, positioning itself for the electric vehicle transition and future fuel consumption trends.

Celebrity Partnerships

The collaboration with Food Network Chef Andrew Zimmern to relaunch BBQ Brisket Pizza demonstrates innovative marketing and product development capabilities.

Strong Financial Metrics

With a return on equity of 16.18% and efficient capital allocation, Casey’s demonstrates superior operational execution compared to sector peers.

🛡️ Beginner Trader Action Plan

Humorous veteran advice: “Trading CASY is like their pizza—best enjoyed hot but dangerous if you grab it too early. Let it cool to the right temperature before taking a big bite!”

✅ How to Buy Casey’s General Stores, Inc. (CASY) Shares – Step by Step

💡 Why Pocket Option Excels for New Investors

For those beginning their investment journey, Pocket Option offers several distinct advantages for building positions in stocks like CASY:

🌍 Casey’s in 2025: America’s Neighborhood Store

Casey’s General Stores has evolved far beyond traditional convenience retail. The company now operates as an integrated fuel, food, and community services provider across rural America. Their strategic focus on prepared foods—particularly pizza—has created a unique competitive moat that distinguishes them from competitors.

The company’s three-year strategic plan focuses on five key initiatives: store expansion, food business acceleration, operational efficiency, community engagement, and financial strength buildingProject Practical.

2025 Interesting Fact: Casey’s recently became the first convenience store chain to install perfume-dispensing elevators at their corporate headquarters—each floor emits a different signature scent, and employees vote weekly on their favorite fragrances!